(Hey Poptropicans! This is a guest post written by Magic Snowball, a Poptropica player in the community. Please note that this post represents only the author’s opinion, and contains some spoilers for some Poptropica islands. Enjoy! âđ )

Hey everyone! Itâs me, Magic Snowball, that weirdo who hangs around the Poptropica community. And today Iâm here to do a Pop 5 – my first guest post! What’s the topic, you ask? I presentâŠ
Poptropica’s Top 5 Most Dangerous/Scary Islands! *cue dramatic music*
Of course, all the islands on this list are going to involve something⊠er, dangerous⊠and scary. Like going inside somewhere dangerous, getting jump-scared (Jersey Devil, anyone?) and so on. And yes, I know Poptropicans are basically OP super-humans, but still, they do some pretty crazy stuffâŠ
So let’s begin the Pop 5!
#5: Twisted Thicket Island

Behold! The island where you must travel into this creepy forest, get beaten up by all these creatures, then save the forest and creatures that beat you up! So, why did I choose this island? Well, firstly, itâs not only dangerous, but scary. I mean, look at the NĂžkken! That thing is nightmare is fuel⊠*shivers* And, like I said, you get beat up by these other woodland creatures, and then you have to stop an entire team of construction vehicles! If that isnât dangerous, I donât know what is.
Poptropica rates this island easy, and it might be, but itâs definitely still scary and dangerous⊠*hides from the NĂžkken*
#4: Astro-Knights Island

Aliens, frustration, flying in zero-gravity! What could be more fun than that? This island, according to many people (myself included) is one of the hardest to complete. And itâs also pretty dangerous. I mean, youâre flying into space to save a princess from a half-robot creepo. And space is not fun. There are things trying to kill you on every planet (except for the Pewter Moon), and even in the space around them.
This isnât the scariest island, but creatures like the Mother Phoenix are pretty creepy (to me at least).This islandâs a little too dangerous to be left off the list, but itâs not the most terrifying. En garde!
#3: Survival Island

Survival Island! This five-part island is full of fun things like being chased by a psychopath, then catching said psychopath! Now, this island doesnât have the traditional “scary” things like monsters or flaming meteorites, but it is realistic. Thereâs the element of survival (well, duh), hunting, and animals. You always have to be on the move, and you canât trust anyone. Thatâs why I consider it pretty dangerous. Plus, you’ve got someone hunting you and so they can stuff you in their trophy collection, which is pretty messed up!
#2: Virus Hunter Island

Welcome to Glitch Island – uh, I mean, Virus Hunter Island! Guess what, kids? Youâre not a trained pilot. So what happens? You get to drive through someoneâs body in a microscopic ship to stop a killer virus! Isnât that awesome?
Alright, seriously, this island is pretty scary and dangerous. You’re stopping a killer virus from killing every human on Earth. Plus, the virus itself is pretty scary. I donât wanna talk âbout it⊠weâll just say the island is full of danger. PDC, green spider-like killers, dangerous grape soda, electric nerves, falafel⊠the list goes on!
And now, itâs time for the most dangerous, most scary island on allllll of PoptropicaâŠ.
*drumroll* It’s…
#1: Mythology Island

Okay, this island and Virus Hunter had me a bit stumped, but in the end I chose this island to top the list, âcause itâs just that dangerous, and the peril you’re in feels worse (though itâs still really close). Dude. AnywayâŠ. You arrive on this island, where thereâs gods and creatures and stuff. You go to a tree, and pick an apple. Then, Santa Claus – uh, Zeus – shows up, and offers you immortality! But first, you have to get some stuff for him so he can take over Poptropica, but you donât realize. Yay!
So you, a mortal, do a bunch of dangerous things, like enter the Labyrinth where barely anyone survives. According to mythology, anyway. Oh, not dangerous enough? Then you have to go to the freaking Underworld, and put flipping Cerberus to sleep, as well as crossing the River Styx. And it gets worse! At the end, you have to fight a god – not just anyone, but the king of the gods. Nuts, huh? Too many times you could die on this island.
If you don’t beat Zeus, all of Poptropica is screwed! Thatâs scary in itself. Plus, there are some other creepy things on this island, like those Hercules fan girls. Oh, and the Underworld, the sphinx, the minotaur, the hydra, and it goes onâŠ
Alright guys! Those islands were the Pop 5 of scariest and most dangerous. Now itâs time for some honorable mentions!
HM: Cryptids Island

This island, if on the list, would be #6. Itâs definitely got the scary element (Jersey Devil and the Chupacabra), and itâs dangerous, but not the most dangerous. Still a good island, though.
HM: Monster Carnival Island

The lost island! Yep, definitely creepy (especially that lab⊠oh gods), and monster-filled! Though it isnât particularly dangerous- really only the monsters are dangerous. Oh, and Ringmaster Raven, who tries to hypnotise everyone. But no, itâs not the most dangerous, so I left it out.
HM: Super Villain Island

Guess what guys? Zeus is back, and heâs more annoying than ever! This time, heâs kidnapped four super villains, and we have to enter their dangerous dreams! Yay! Then, at the end, we have to fight Zeus again, and the fight is more life-threatening than Mythology Islandâs! Although itâs dangerous, it just isnât scary enough, so I left it out.
Alrighty, ladies and gents! Thatâs all I have to say for this list, so thank you for reading and Iâll see you around in the Poptropica community! đ
â
Hope you enjoyed this guest post by Magic Snowball!
The PHB welcomes guest posting from anyone in our community if you have something to share, whether it be sneak peeks, My Place in Poptropica stories, or any other ideas you might have. We also encourage sharing on the PHC.
If you have an idea for a guest post, send it in to [email protected]!Â
The top 5 are just dangerous. The HMs were more scary imo. Still,good list!
Tbh I judged more on danger rather than scariness XD But thanks!
Santa Zeus. ‘Nough said. XD
Personally I think survival is the creepiest and I love mythology island. Plus Virus Hunter is pretty fun, put you know, that’s my opinion đ
Everyone’s got their own opinions, I guess XD
Spoop! Nice list!
Thanks!
Asto-Knights being one of the hardest? Don’t get me started on Skullduggery or Mystery Train. Good list tho! đ
Thanks! AK is pretty hard…
Super Power Island?
Thanks for posting this! Glad people generally agree XD And thanks for doing the photos, you guys rule!
Thanks for writing in! đ
No problem!
Survival FTW
Monster Carnival was definitely the scariest to me! Almost like FNAF really.